|
Earlier this week, I wrote about the second of the “four last things”: judgment. I don't want to spoil the ending, but we eventually arrive at one of two destinations: Hell (the subject of next week's essay) or Heaven (the following week). But what about purgatory? Doesn't it make sense that there might be a way station along the journey home?
A few years ago, in an All Saints' Day sermon, I told a joke about Irish Catholic Grandma O'Hanlon, who is consigned to languish in purgatory until the Cleveland Browns win a Super Bowl, while German Lutheran Grandma Schmidt gets fast-tracked through the system. It got the laugh it deserved. But the point I was trying to make was more serious: we know that being forgiven and being finished are not the same thing. Yet that doesn't necessarily mean there's a waiting room between the two. In other words, the gap is real, but the clock may not be. Two weeks ago, I wrote about the economy the late medieval church built around that gap. Masses had a price, relief had a schedule, and the dead had become somebody's revenue stream. The Reformers' objections to that system still stand. But dismantling a marketplace doesn't necessarily answer the question that marketplace claimed to address. As Lutherans, we know who finishes us. We've often found it harder to articulate exactly what that finishing entails. What Happens to the Grudge? Think of someone you loved who died in Jesus. She was baptized, received Communion, and believed. She also held a grudge against her sister for thirty years and never quite let it go. You loved her, and you knew both things were true. Scripture says nothing unclean will enter the new Jerusalem (Revelation 21:27). It also says she is saved by grace, not by her scorecard (Ephesians 2:8–9). So what happens to that grudge? Does it come through the door with her? We can trust the promise that God finishes his saints. How he does that is another question. I want to hold on to the promise without pretending we know every detail. Luther's answer in the Large Catechism is shorter than you might expect. The Holy Spirit begins and increases holiness in us here, through the church and the forgiveness of sins. Then, “in our dissolution,” Luther says, “He will accomplish it altogether in an instant.” Dissolution refers to the body's breaking down at death. The surrounding passage points toward resurrection and perfect holiness in a glorified body. That is a promise that God will complete his work, not a description of what it will feel like. Luther does not tell us how it happens or whether it hurts (Luther, Large Catechism, II.57–59). You might call this “instant purgatory.” The nickname has some humor and some truth, as long as we don't ask it to settle an argument that has barely begun. Being fully accepted in Christ and being fully healed of sin are gifts we can distinguish. Neither is something we buy. That does not make Lutherans secretly Roman Catholic. The differences still matter. The Reformers rejected the system of satisfactions, merits, indulgences, and Masses applied as payment for the dead. Satisfactions are acts meant to make amends for sin. Merits are spiritual worth credited to good works. Indulgences are releases from penalties for sin other than eternal condemnation. We can stand with the Reformers in rejecting that system and still ask the questions it tried, however badly, to answer. Catholic theology, too, has more to offer than the Browns joke suggests. In Spe Salvi (Saved in Hope), Benedict XVI described purification as a transforming encounter with Christ. Its “duration,” he wrote, cannot be calculated by earthly clocks. That does not erase the differences between Catholic and Lutheran teaching. Nor does it mean Benedict abandoned Catholic teaching about purification. But it does challenge the familiar picture of purgatory as a prison sentence measured in years (Benedict XVI, Spe Salvi, §47). A Lutheran who says “instantly” and a Catholic who says “not measurable in years” have not settled their disagreement.But perhaps they can stop arguing about the clock. Both are trying to describe something our everyday measures of time cannot capture. Falling asleep here and waking up there does not require a waiting room. Whatever the encounter involves, Benedict's account does not reduce it to one. We are not the first to notice this possible meeting point. The U.S. Lutheran–Catholic dialogue's The Hope of Eternal Life takes up final transformation, purgatory, and prayer for the dead. It even considers this same passage from the Large Catechism. The report does not settle the question for every Lutheran church. Still, it reminds us that the conversation is not new. Joining it need not mean giving up Lutheran convictions (U.S. Lutheran–Catholic Dialogue, The Hope of Eternal Life, 2010). At the same time, we owe the Reformers a fair hearing. The Smalcald Articles offer much more than a polite “no.” Luther rejects purgatory along with the rites and commerce attached to it. His concern is not simply that someone charged admission. He sees the teaching as contradicting the chief article: Jesus alone frees souls. That said, the confessions—the church's formal statements of faith—also make a distinction worth keeping. The Apology does not prohibit prayer for the dead. It notes that ancient Christian writers practiced it. What it rejects is applying the Lord's Supper to the dead as though performing the rite itself delivers the benefit. That leaves genuine room for prayer, but not for treating the sacrament as a way to secure benefits for the departed (Apology of the Augsburg Confession, XXIV.89–96, especially §94). Then we come to 1 Corinthians 3, a passage that often comes up in this conversation. St. Paul says the Day will reveal each builder's work with fire. What survives is rewarded; what burns up is lost. The builder himself is saved, “but only as through fire” (1 Corinthians 3:13–15). We need to handle this text with care. Paul is speaking mainly about the work of those who build up the church, not about the dead in general. Luther did not use it as proof of purgatory, and neither do I. St. Paul is not drawing us a map of the afterlife. His words do not settle our question, but they give us an image we can borrow: fire that tests and burns away what doesn't belong, yet does not destroy the person. We can hold that picture without turning it into a doctrine. It gives us a way to speak about the completion promised in the Large Catechism without claiming to explain how it works. What might that fire be? Some Christians have pictured it not as a furnace God lights beneath us, but as an encounter with God himself. In that same section of Spe Salvi, Benedict describes the gaze of Jesus, before which falsehood melts away. It is an encounter that burns, transforms, and frees us (Benedict XVI, Spe Salvi, §47). C. S. Lewis offered another picture in Letters to Malcolm: Chiefly on Prayer. A soul asks to be washed before meeting God, hears that it might hurt, and answers, “Even so, sir” (Lewis, Letters to Malcolm, Letter XX). Here is my own guess, offered as a guess and nothing more. Perhaps we finally see our lives without the blinders: how our sins harmed people we loved, people we barely noticed, and even our enemies. Perhaps we recognize the excuses we held on to and the people we refused to see. And perhaps Jesus's love helps us face that truth, even as it leaves us nowhere to hide from it. If that encounter brings grief, the grief is not our price of admission. It is what healing might feel like when we no longer have anything to hide. I cannot claim that Scripture describes it this way. I simply find it a helpful way to imagine St. Paul's “loss” alongside Luther's promise of completion. In this picture, the fire is an encounter with Jesus, not punishment to pay a debt. It burns the baggage without burning the person. The loss is grief over what must go, not a balance still owed. The Fire Is Not God Collecting Here is the point I most want you to hear, because it keeps this whole conversation Lutheran. If talk of being finishedsounds like a back door for works or merit, I understand the concern. But that is not what I mean by sanctification, the Spirit's work of making us holy. None of it is payment. Jesus's satisfaction is complete. The debt is canceled. There is no balance left for us to work off. The fire pays no debt. It changes us. Luther's simul justus et peccator—at once righteous and a sinner—helps us name the reality we live with. We are completely justified—declared righteous—in Christ, yet we remain sinners who need the Spirit to make us holy. At the baptismal font, God gives us Jesus and his righteousness. That promise does not wait for us to improve. Nor is the forgiveness we hear throughout our lives an installment plan. The Large Catechism places daily forgiveness through Word, sacrament, and absolution—the spoken assurance of forgiveness—at the center of our life in the Spirit (Luther, Large Catechism, II.54–59). Sanctification is the Spirit's long work in us, still unfinished in this life. The Large Catechism promises that he will complete it. Some Lutherans will want to say that this work is complete at death. I am not denying that. Whatever the timing, the completion belongs to God, not to us. The fire is not God collecting. It is God finishing. Love Beyond the Death Certificate We don't have to know how God finishes his work before we entrust the people we have lost to him. The Apology's allowance for prayer for the dead does not depend on accepting my picture of the fire (Apology of the Augsburg Confession, XXIV.94). For a baptized Christian who rests in the hands of the God who will finish his work in her, prayer need not mean bargaining with an accountant. It can simply be love that does not stop at the death certificate. We can commend her to God's keeping without guessing at a balance owed, a timetable, or some spiritual task we must carry out for her. There is also comfort in knowing that prayer is not confined to our side of death. We need to be careful, though, about what we claim. The Apology grants that the saints in heaven pray for the church in general. It does not establish that they hear our individual petitions or watch every moment of our lives. Still, the church is not divided into living people who matter and departed people who no longer belong (Apology of the Augsburg Confession, XXI.9–13). That is why All Saints is more than a memorial service. We cannot see the departed, but they have not been cut off from Jesus or his church. They are the saints who have gone ahead of us. We are the saints still stumbling along the road. I also want to be clear about what I am not saying. This is not a second chance for those who die refusing Jesus. Hebrews says we die once, and then comes judgment (Hebrews 9:27). The next essay in this series will say more about judgment and hell. Nothing here makes death a small matter or removes judgment. And no one needs my picture of purification to be saved. We are given Jesus's word and his promise at the baptismal font. A Christian who has never thought about purgatory is in no worse position than one who has. My aim is smaller and closer to the questions people bring when they are grieving. I want to offer an honest answer to someone who asks whether her mother—a believer whose struggles were not yet over—made it through the door. The answer is yes, because the one who began the work is faithful to complete it (Philippians 1:6). You may call that finishing instantaneous. You may prefer not to measure it by earthly clocks. You may even think I am making a furnace sound too comforting. Beneath those differences, the promise remains: God loves us too much to leave us as we are. Grandma O'Hanlon and Grandma Schmidt can compare notes on the timing when they get there. What both were counting on was Jesus—the one who does not merely open the door, but brings his unfinished people home. Rev. Dr. Steve Stutz Ordained Lutheran Pastor · Intentional Interim Minister · Certified Spiritual Director La Porte, Texas · Houston Area [Contact] · [LinkedIn] · [The Marginal Note on Substack] The Marginal Note — Theology for people who are still paying attention. Free monthly newsletter. Subscribe at Substack. ©2026 Steve Stutz. All rights reserved. Brief quotes welcome with attribution; full reprints require permission. Details at https://www.stevestutz.com (bottom of page) And finally... yes, I use AI as an editorial tool in producing this blog — feedback on structure, grammar, clarity, possible revisions to avoid lawsuits and liable, etc. Most of the images are AI generated to avoid copyright issues and the others are given proper attribution. I'll often send AI on "step and fetch" errands: chasing down a statistic, tracking a quote or source I don't have at my fingertips. Any autobiographical material, obviously, is mine alone. Before anything gets published, I review it, revise it, and verify every claim as best I can. AI makes mistakes. I know that and I work hard to make sure none of those get past me. At the end of the day, I stand behind every word that runs under my name on this blog and on The Marginal Note, hosted over on Substack. In both places, you get better content, with all the profanity and heresy edited out. It’s a “win-win” for everyone.
0 Comments
A Lutheran pastor on why the last hours of life are a fight on both sides of the line of scrimmage, and why “Baptizatus sum” answers both attacks. A deathbed can feel like a battleground, and the devil knows how to press from either side. He whispers one thing to the person who has spent eighty years avoiding God, and something very different to the person who has spent those same years trying faithfully to serve him. Luther’s answer to both was the same two words: Baptizatus sum, “I am baptized.”
This post follows one thread from this week’s full essay over at The Marginal Note on the first of the Four Last Things: death. If you have ever sat beside someone in their final hours and wondered why the room could feel so unsettled—or wondered what any of us can hold onto when everything else is slipping away—this is for you. Fourth and One at the Goal Line Pastors, chaplains, and hospice nurses recognize the signs: restlessness, a sudden fear in someone who had been calm for weeks, or the confession of something long kept hidden. Some of this is physiology, of course. Christians have also long understood that some of it may be spiritual. Hebrews says Jesus came to free those held in lifelong slavery by the fear of death (2:14-15). St. Peter says the devil prowls like a lion looking for someone to devour (1 Peter 5:8), and Revelation calls him the accuser (12:10). Martin Luther had a word for this experience: Anfechtung, a severe spiritual assault. He believed it could become especially sharp at the hour of death. I sometimes tell people to picture fourth-and-one at the goal line. Both sides know the game is nearly over, so the struggle intensifies right up to the whistle. That is why a calm face on the pillow does not necessarily mean the struggle is over. Sometimes it simply means the struggle has gone quiet. The Attack on the Lifelong Lout Begin with a man who has spent eighty years running from God. He drank, cheated, and slept through every funeral he attended, even his mother’s. Now he lies in a hospital bed. The pain has stripped away the swagger, and somewhere beneath the fog a small, honest thought rises: I need help. From the devil’s side of the line of scrimmage, that thought is the emergency. Eighty years of patient work leading this man to eternal perdition could be undone by one act of faith—a single sentence—uttered in raspy voice at the last breath! So, the Accuser goes into damage control mode and sets to work, but not with temptation. He tries the opposite: “Too late, Bob. That ship has sailed. You had plenty of chances to take God up on his grace, but you weren’t interested when it was a drag on your lifestyle. Hypocrite! You don’t even mean it now, really. If God healed you in this moment you’d go right back to your old life. You’re just a coward who is fearing the bill come due. God has no use for a deathbed convert who has mocked him for decades. Remember all those things you did? Don’t embarrass yourself or me with this repentance nonsense.” Notice that he never has to argue the man is innocent. He only has to persuade him that the promise has an expiration date. Scripture gives us the thief on the cross. In his final hours he asks only to be remembered, and Jesus answers him: “Today you will be with me in Paradise” (Luke 23:42-43). An old line, traditionally attributed to St. Augustine, says that one such conversion is recorded “so that none may despair, and only one so that none may presume.” We need both halves. A deathbed rescue is not a plan anyone should count on. But when it comes, it is received as a gift, not achieved as a feat.Even the cry “I need help” is the Holy Spirit’s work in someone who could not have summoned it alone. The Attack on the Devout Now consider the other bedside. A woman has gone to church for eighty years. She taught Sunday school, chaired the altar guild, brought casseroles when someone died, showed up whenever the church needed volunteers, and tithed even when it hurt. She knows the hymns by heart, including the verses we usually skip. The devil uses a different script withher. He does not say it is too late or that she never believed. He simply opens the record: “Remember what you said about your sister? Remember the resentment you carried for thirty years? Remember the thing you never confessed to anyone? Remember the person you refused to forgive? Remember that time you knew you were wrong and blamed somebody else anyway? Remember the secret you have carried all these years? Everybody thinks you’re a saint. You fooled them all. You fooled your children. You fooled your pastor. You fooled the whole congregation. Do you really think God was fooled?” Strangely enough, a devout person may feel especially exposed here. She has spent a lifetime taking faithfulness seriously, and at the bedside the Accuser turns that seriousness against her. If her comfort has quietly begun to rest on her own record, he knows exactly where to press. Every hidden sin becomes another piece of evidence. His goal is the same as before: despair. The faith that carried her for eighty years turns inward in the final hour and begins auditing itself. This is why Lutherans don’t treat faith as an insurance policy that can’t be cancelled. We hold that God preserves his own, and we also hold that faith can be lost, so the last hours matter. Eighty years of hard-won virtue can be tanked at the whistle if what she is holding is her record rather than her Lord. Why the Bar Is Low, and Why That Is the Target Jesus tells a parable about a vineyard owner who hires workers at dawn, at nine, at noon, at three, and at five, an hour before quitting time. At the end of the day he pays everyone the same denarius (Matthew 20:1-16). The all-day workers are furious. The eleventh-hour workers can hardly believe it. The kingdom opens on a promise, not a résumé. That is the best news in the world—and it is also why the deathbed becomes contested ground. The devil cannot raise the bar, because it is not his to move. So, he attacks the promise instead. To the person who came late, he says the promise cannot possibly be for him. To the person who came early, he says she has disqualified herself. The lies sound different, but they aim at the same thing: getting a dying person to answer “Am I in?” by looking inward. Baptizatus Sum Luther’s answer to the Accuser was wonderfully short. Tradition says that when the attacks came, he wrote Baptizatus sum where he could see it. I have never found a better two-word defense. Notice what it does. It concedes the charge. It doesn’t say, “Actually, I’ve been pretty good,” and it doesn’t say, “Actually, it isn’t too late.” It lets the accusation stand and points somewhere else. It also relocates the question. “Am I in?” is no longer answered by examining my record or my last-minute sincerity. It is answered by something God did, at a particular time and place, with my name attached (Romans 6:3-4, Galatians 3:27). And it names the owner. When the devil accuses a baptized person of her sins, he is bringing charges against someone whose debts have already been taken by Another. That is why it works for both people. For the lout, baptized as a baby in a church he hasn’t seen in sixty years, it means the promise didn’t lapse. His side of the arrangement fell apart long ago, but God’s side never did. Like the father in the story of the prodigal son, God kept watching the road. For the devout woman, it takes the file out of her hands. Whatever is written in the record, there is something on the font that is bigger, and she didn’t write that either. This is not a magic phrase. It is a confession of what God has done. Luther meant it to become a habit for the whole Christian life, not merely an emergency sentence at the end. The Large Catechism describes the Christian life as a daily return to baptism. That is why these words belong not only at the bedside, but also on ordinary mornings when we are still healthy and the day is just beginning. What It Sounds Like in the Room Two composite scenes, not real people. Over at the Sisters of Mercy Hospital, in Room 212, Walter hasn’t darkened a church door in over sixty years and is frightened. His daughter invited her pastor to visit him before the end came. When the pastor shows up, he doesn’t ask for a decision. He says, “Walter, you were baptized as a baby. God didn’t forget it. The promise made that day is still standing, and so is he. You don’t have to explain yourself or prove anything. If you have breath for three words, ‘Lord, have mercy’ will do. If you don’t, I’ll say it for you.” In Room 510, Sara has been faithful all her life and is wracked with guilt over what she never confessed. Her pastor lays a hand on her head and says, “Sara, your baptism is not a memory. It is a present reality. God’s name was written on you. When the devil accuses you of your sins, he is accusing the One who died for them.” Then, as “a called and ordained minister of the church of Christ, and by his authority,” he speaks Absolution over her, and tells her that is God’s last word on the matter. Even if you are not the pastor, you can still offer something precious. Keep the promise simple: “You are baptized. God put his name on you, and he has not let go.” Read Psalm 23 or Romans 8:38-39 slowly. Hold a hand. If it fits your tradition, trace a cross on the person’s forehead. If they cannot respond, speak anyway; hearing is often said to be among the last senses to fade. This is not the time for a quiz about faith or a request for one final statement. It is a time to give the promise freely. Call your pastor early. Absolution, the Commendation of the Dying, and the Lord’s Supper are gifts to a dying person, and pastors would much rather be called too soon than too late. If the person was never baptized, call right away. Pastors baptize the dying, and in an emergency any baptized Christian may do so with water and the Trinitarian words. Practice Before You Need It Think of the phrase as a muscle. The Accuser tends to show up when we are too tired or frightened to build one, so it helps to practice now. When the water hits your face in the shower, try saying aloud, “Hey—I am baptized!” It may feel a little silly. That is part of the point: grace meets us in ordinary places, too. A day will come—for us and for people we love—when the machines grow quiet and a chair waits beside the bed. In that moment, we will not need a speech. We will need a promise. And this is one we can carry with us now. This is the first Thursday follow-up in a November series on the Four Last Things. For the longer, more theological argument about deathbed ministry, read this week’s essay at The Marginal Note. Rev. Dr. Steve Stutz Ordained Lutheran Pastor · Intentional Interim Minister · Certified Spiritual Director La Porte, Texas · Houston Area [Contact] · [LinkedIn] · [The Marginal Note on Substack] The Marginal Note — Theology for people who are still paying attention. Free monthly newsletter. Subscribe at Substack. ©2026 Steve Stutz. All rights reserved. Brief quotes welcome with attribution; full reprints require permission. Details at https://www.stevestutz.com (bottom of page) And finally... yes, I use AI as an editorial tool in producing this blog — feedback on structure, grammar, clarity, possible revisions to avoid lawsuits and liable, etc. Most of the images are AI generated to avoid copyright issues and the others are given proper attribution. I'll often send AI on "step and fetch" errands: chasing down a statistic, tracking a quote or source I don't have at my fingertips. Any autobiographical material, obviously, is mine alone. Before anything gets published, I review it, revise it, and verify every claim as best I can. AI makes mistakes. I know that and I work hard to make sure none of those get past me. At the end of the day, I stand behind every word that runs under my name on this blog and on The Marginal Note, hosted over on Substack. In both places, you get better content, with all the profanity and heresy edited out. It’s a “win-win” for everyone. Part 5 of Deliverance in Context (From the Ground Up!)
Halloween stirs up strong feelings: fun, nostalgia, curiosity, caution, and sometimes real spiritual concern. This is a short pastoral reflection, not a finger-wag, but an invitation to think faithfully about what we celebrate, what we avoid, and where we place our trust. Big Business, Old Story Americans are expected to spend $13.5 billion on Halloween this year, according to the National Retail Federation: about $4.4 billion on costumes, $4.3 billion on decorations, and $4.1 billion on candy, or roughly $115 per person. That is a lot of fun-size candy bars. Mixing the season of the dead with commerce is nothing new. In the late Middle Ages, the days around All Saints' and All Souls' (October 31–November 2) were a major economic engine for the Church. Indulgences promised to shorten time in purgatory for the living or the dead. In Wittenberg, the Castle Church housed one of Europe's largest relic collections, put on display each All Saints' Day for crowds who earned indulgences by viewing them. That was the world Martin Luther stepped into. On October 31, 1517, All Hallows' Eve, he posted (or at least mailed) his Ninety-Five Theses, timed for the moment when everyone was already paying attention. What began as a call for debate exposed how thoroughly the fear of death and the fate of souls had become a revenue stream. Seasons Have Layers Christmas looks like presents and lights from the outside, but for Christians it carries the mystery of the Incarnation. Halloween has layers too. For most families it is costumes, candy, and neighbors. For some occult circles, it carries a different kind of spiritual weight. No need to panic, but it is worth being sober-minded. Harmless Fun, and Where It Stops Haul the ghoul gear up from the basement. Carve the pumpkin. Hand out the candy. Memories of costumes and porch lights are genuinely sweet, and nothing here is meant to rain on that. But Halloween has roots in the Celtic festival of Samhain, associated with the belief that the veil between the living and the dead grows thin. Wiccan and neopagan handbooks openly describe Samhain as an especially potent time for divination, spell work, and contacting the dead. Caution Without Panic Evil is real, and demonic influence is not a medieval superstition we have outgrown. The Small Catechism's explanation of the Second Commandment warns us against practicing magic, and Luther observed that where God builds a church, the devil is likely to build a chapel nearby. Practices worth avoiding include Ouija boards, rituals aimed at contacting the dead, divination, spellcasting, psychics, and modern witchcraft. Even gentler-sounding neopagan practices still reach for the spiritual world outside of God's revelation. Many people who come to the church seeking relief from demonic harassment say their trouble began after dabbling in exactly these things. Some adult-oriented haunted houses and performances that glorify the occult deserve the same discernment. Trick-or-treating and church trunk-or-treats are generally innocent and enjoyable. Paul reminds us (Ephesians 6:12) that our struggle is not against flesh and blood but against spiritual forces of evil. Choose what you participate in accordingly. Confident in Christ None of this means tiptoeing through October holding your breath. Luther's hymn gives bracing assurance: "The Prince of Darkness grim, we tremble not for him; one little word shall fell him." That is not bravado but settled faith in Jesus' victory over sin, death, and evil. We can be discerning without being fearful, joyful without being naive, and playful without being spiritually careless. Here are two prayers you are welcome to use: Prayer for Protection "Gracious God, we come before You seeking refuge and strength. We ask for Your protection against any evil that seeks to harm us. Surround us with Your angels and shield us with Your grace. May we find comfort in Your presence and courage in our faith. We trust in the promise of Psalm 91: 'He will cover you with his feathers, and under his wings you will find refuge.' Help us to stand firm against any attacks and to rely on Your Word for strength. In Jesus' name, we pray. Amen." Prayer for Deliverance "Heavenly Father, we come to You in our hour of need, asking for deliverance from any darkness that seeks to invade our lives. We acknowledge that You are the Light of the World and that darkness cannot overcome You. As we face any spiritual challenges, grant us the discernment to recognize evil and the strength to resist it. We claim the victory of Christ over sin and darkness, as promised in John 1:5: 'The light shines in the darkness, and the darkness has not overcome it.' Please cleanse our hearts and minds, and fill us with Your Holy Spirit. We ask this in the mighty name of Jesus Christ. Amen." Living in the Light So let your jack-o'-lanterns shine. Enjoy the glittering princesses, tiny superheroes, and inflatable dinosaurs, and let the season draw you back to prayer, discernment, and the steady comfort of the Gospel. We do not belong to the darkness. We belong to Jesus, the Light who shines in the darkness, and the darkness has not overcome Him. P.S. Remember what comes the very next day: All Saints' Day, November 1. That is where we are truly headed, surrounded by "a great cloud of witnesses" (Hebrews 12:1), with Jesus' victory over sin, death, and every power of darkness already won. This is the final installment of Deliverance in Context. The full-length version of this essay, with additional historical detail, is at [LINK: Beyond Costumes on The Marginal Note]. Previous installments of this series are located here. Rev. Dr. Steve Stutz Ordained Lutheran Pastor · Intentional Interim Minister · Certified Spiritual Director La Porte, Texas · Houston Area [Contact] · [LinkedIn] · [The Marginal Note on Substack] The Marginal Note — Theology for people who are still paying attention. Free monthly newsletter. Subscribe at Substack. ©2026 Steve Stutz. All rights reserved. Brief quotes welcome with attribution; full reprints require permission. Details at https://www.stevestutz.com (bottom of page) This is Part 4 of a 5-part series on spiritual warfare and pastoral care. In Part 1, we looked at curses, wounding words, and spiritual freedom. In Part 2, we turned to pastoral care for places—home blessings, spiritual discernment, and what may be happening when a particular space simply feels wrong. Part 3 was a discussion about territorial spirits and strategic-level spiritual warfare—and to the question of why binding “the spirit over the city” from a hotel conference room is not quite how any of this works. Now we take up the topic of “systemic” or “structural” deliverance.
The Wall I have sat through more than one council meeting where a good idea quietly died—even though no one actually opposed it. Someone suggests extending the pantry hours, opening the fellowship hall to a recovery group, or using part of the reserve to meet a neighbor’s need. Heads nod. No one argues. But the room cools. Questions about liability and cost begin to pile up. Someone says, “Not here, not now,” and the motion is tabled until a date that never comes. No one in that room is a villain. Most are faithful people who have poured decades of love, work, and money into the church. Still, the wall is real, and it is not built from any one person’s bad intentions. Every pastor who has tried to help a congregation turn outward toward its neighbors has felt it. Earlier parts of this series focused on persons, households, and places: inherited patterns, freedom for individuals, and the blessing of homes and spaces. But sometimes the trouble runs deeper. The bondage has settled into the system itself, and praying with one person or over one building does not make it disappear. By structural deliverance, I do not mean treating a congregation or institution like a person in need of an exorcism. I mean the Spirit-dependent work of honestly naming the powers of sin at work in our shared life, confessing the harm they have caused, and changing the practices that allow that harm to keep repeating. What Are We Actually Fighting? When Paul writes that our struggle is not against flesh and blood but against "the rulers, against the authorities, against the cosmic powers of this present darkness, against the spiritual forces of evil in the heavenly places" (Eph. 6:12, NRSVUE), he is not licensing us to blame people for everything that goes wrong. He is saying evil is larger than individual bad behavior. Sin gathers momentum. It settles into customs, fears, incentives, stories, policies, and institutional habits. People can participate in harm without setting out to do harm—and sometimes without even seeing it. That does not excuse anyone. It does remind us that the problem may be bigger than one person’s intentions and more stubborn than one person’srepentance. Paul says creation itself is in “bondage to decay,” waiting for the freedom of the children of God (Rom. 8:20–21, NRSVUE). God’s redemptive purpose reaches persons, communities, and the created order. Walter Wink spent his trilogy The Powers arguing something close to this: that the "principalities and powers" of the New Testament are not simply invisible beings floating above institutions but something closer to the inner spirituality of institutions themselves, the animating character an organization takes on and defends, for good or ill. A zoning board, a corporation, or a congregation's council has a "spirit" in exactly this sense. That spirit can be turned from its created purpose and become, in Wink's phrase, domination rather than service. However one weighs Wink's proposal against a more traditional account of the powers as personal spiritual beings distinct from institutions, his instinct is sound for a pastor standing in a stuck council meeting: the structure itself can be sick in a way no individual member is. Lutherans already pray this. Luther's explanation of the Lord's Prayer takes "deliver us from evil" to mean deliverance from every evil of body and soul, property and honor. Property and honor are not private matters. The ELCA's foundational social statement, The Church in Society (1991), makes the same move: the God who justifies also expects justice, so the church's public witness belongs to its confession of Christ. This is not a modern add-on to the Gospel. What Systemic Captivity Looks Like What does that kind of captivity look like on an ordinary Tuesday in parish life? Consider three familiar scenarios. The Ministry Blocked by Memory A parish tries to partner with a minority-led community center, and every meeting is strangely tense. Small disagreements turn charged. Goodwill evaporates. Then leaders begin to research and discover that sixty years ago the church's leadership supported discriminatory zoning that displaced the very community it now hopes to serve. Most current members knew nothing about it. But what was never truthfully named still shapes public memory and neighborhood trust. Scripture does not let us answer, "That was before our time." Israel's prayers of confession keep to the first person plural: "We have sinned; we have done wrong" (Dan. 9:5, NRSVUE). Nehemiah confesses his own sins alongside "those of my ancestors" (Neh. 1:6–7, NRSVUE). The ELCA's Freed in Christ: Race, Ethnicity, and Culture(1993) names racism as sin and calls the church to examine its own part in it. The Master Called Security A congregation holds substantial reserves for understandable reasons: deferred maintenance, pension obligations, the memory of a lean year. Prudence quietly becomes self-protection when fear makes mission impossible. Picture that congregation surrounded by hungry and unhoused neighbors, unable to consider any real generosity because every conversation is governed by the dread of running out. The question is not whether to plan responsibly. It is whether money has become the master that decides whom the church is willing to love. "You cannot serve God and wealth" (Matt. 6:24, NRSVUE). The ELCA's Sufficient, Sustainable Livelihood for All (1999) observes that economic life is marked by sin and that injustice can become embedded in economic arrangements. A church's endowment policy is one of those arrangements. The Unspoken "Who Belongs" Code A church sincerely prays for new people. Then neighbors arrive who are poorer, or from a different culture, or in unfamiliar family shapes, and a defensiveness settles over the sanctuary. It shows in who gets greeted and who gets ignored, in whose children are welcome and whose are "disruptive," in assumptions about clothing, speech, music, and what counts as fitting behavior. The congregation never says, "You don't belong here." Its habits say it anyway, usually in respectable language like "tradition" and "how we do things here." James asks the church that plays favorites, "Have you not made distinctions among yourselves, and become judges with evil thoughts?" (James 2:4, NRSVUE). In all three cases the people are not necessarily bad people. They are faithful people caught in patterns larger than themselves, and the powers exploit fear and habit until the church's common life contradicts the Gospel it proclaims. Before You Call It Demonic A word of caution is important here. Most stuck congregations are not under spiritual assault. They may be anxious, tired, underfunded, poorly organized, or carrying an old conflict no one has resolved. Start with the ordinary explanations.Church systems often get stuck for ordinary reasons, and good pastoral care, honest conversation, and sound process can address many of them. Something larger may be at work when the same pattern outlasts every change of personnel, predates the people now in the room, keeps injuring the neighbor, and resists every sincere and competent attempt at reform. Even then, the language of the powers is for discernment, never for accusation. It must never be used as a weapon against a member or a faction, and no person is ever to be labeled demonic. If the naming makes it easier to blame someone, it is being misused. How a Church Resists If evil is held in place by both spiritual forces and human structures, then our response has to engage both. Prayer without changed practice can become pious avoidance. Structural change without prayer can become one more attempt to save ourselves by competence alone. The church needs both repentance and repair. 1. Truth-Telling Before a congregation can change, it has to learn to see itself clearly. What stories do we tell about who we are, and what parts of our history do we avoid? Whose needs shape the agenda, and whose are treated as inconvenient? Which fears keep deciding things for us? What have we called “normal,” and who has paid the price for that normal? Where do our budget, governance, use of the building, or patterns of welcome contradict the values we say we hold? "You will know the truth, and the truth will make you free" (John 8:32, NRSVUE). The powers thrive on secrecy and confusion, and truth-telling exposes their work. 2. Corporate Confession and Identificational Repentance Corporate repentance does not mean assuming personal guilt for what previous generations did. It means refusing the evasive comfort of "that was before us," and owning what the church chooses to inherit, preserve, deny, or repair. For Lutherans, neighbor love takes the form of neighbor justice, and neighbor justice begins when the church publicly admits where its own systems have failed to love. This should be liturgical, not only administrative, and the charismatic tradition offers a concrete practice worth borrowing here: identificational repentance, prayer that confesses before God the sins of one's own family, church, or people, even sins the pray-er did not personally commit. The pattern is Nehemiah confessing "the sins that we Israelites have sinned," including those of his ancestors and himself (Neh. 1:6–7, NRSVUE), and a psalmist generations after the exodus still praying, "We have sinned as our ancestors did" (Ps. 106:6, NRSVUE). Scripture treats a people, a city, and a congregation as having a life and a history that can be confessed corporately, not only a collection of individuals with private records. In practice, a council or prayer team might do the following before any wider process of reform begins:
3. Reform You Can Measure Prayer does not replace reform. It gives the church courage for the costly work of reform, and repentance becomes credible when it takes visible form. Begin with a history audit: Who built this church? How has it related to its neighborhood? Who was welcomed, and who was left out? Put the budget beside the mission statement and ask whether they tell the same story. Review the bylaws, endowment policy, building-use rules, and patterns of authority. Invite the people most affected to help shape the response rather than asking for their opinion after the decisions are already made. Then choose one visible change to make within a year, because repentance that no one can see is difficult to trust. "Faith by itself, if it has no works, is dead" (James 2:17, NRSVUE). None of this earns righteousness, which Christ alone gives. But "for freedom Christ has set us free" (Gal. 5:1, NRSVUE), and Paul points that freedom straight at the neighbor: "through love become slaves to one another" (Gal. 5:13, NRSVUE). Liberating More Than Individuals If our ministry of deliverance rescues only individuals, we may send freed people back into systems that will wound them all over again. Christ “disarmed the rulers and authorities and made a public example of them, triumphing over them in it”(Col. 2:15, NRSVUE). That victory reaches beyond private souls into congregations, neighborhoods, institutions, and economic life. We still wait for the day when “all things” are made new (Rev. 21:5, NRSVUE), and until then this workwill often be slow. Systems rarely yield quickly. But slowness is not proof that God is absent. So when you meet the wall, resist the urge to fight the people standing in front of you. Begin smaller than you think. At the next council meeting, open with confession. Then ask one honest question: whom does our “normal” cost? Make room for the answers. Keep listening. And keep changing what can be changed. The God who justifies is also the God who breaks the yoke and sets the captives free (Isa. 58:6; Col. 2:15). A practice to carry into the week. Structural change calls for more than good intentions. It asks us to stay prayerful, truthful, and grounded as we face patterns larger than any one person. A Daily Armor Prayer is a free morning practice shaped like a Celtic lorica and woven through with Paul’s language in Ephesians 6. It is a way to remember that the armor is God’s, not ours—and to enter the day ready to resist evil through faithful presence rather than bravado. [Download here.] Next week: Halloween is costumes, candy, and a little spooky fun—but for Christians, there’s more going on beneath the surface. How do we take spiritual realities seriously without becoming fearful or reactionary? And where does All Saints’ Day fit into all of this? Part 5: “Beyond Costumes,” takes a look at Halloween, spiritual discernment, the reality of evil, and the far greater reality of Christ’s victory over it all. Because we don’t have to fear the darkness when we know who holds the light. Rev. Dr. Steve Stutz Ordained Lutheran Pastor · Intentional Interim Minister · Certified Spiritual Director La Porte, Texas · Houston Area [Contact] · [LinkedIn] · [The Marginal Note on Substack] The Marginal Note — Theology for people who are still paying attention. Free monthly newsletter. Subscribe at Substack. ©2026 Steve Stutz. All rights reserved. Brief quotes welcome with attribution; full reprints require permission. Details at https://www.stevestutz.com (bottom of page) This is Part 3 of a 5-part series on spiritual warfare and pastoral care. In Part 1, we looked at curses, wounding words, and spiritual freedom. In Part 2, we turned to pastoral care for places—home blessings, spiritual discernment, and what may be happening when a particular space simply feels wrong. Now, in Part 3, we come to territorial spirits and strategic-level spiritual warfare—and to the question of why binding “the spirit over the city” from a hotel conference room is not quite how any of this works.
Around the year 2000, the local Ministerial Alliance in the West Texas town where I lived launched an ambitious evangelism initiative to deliver a VHS copy of The Jesus Film to every household in the city. To carry out the effort, the alliance divided the city into distinct regions and enlisted prominent local congregations—First Baptist, First Methodist, First Presbyterian, and the growing non-denominational powerhouse—to oversee distribution. The campaign was supported by a strong public presence: ministers wrote columns for the local newspaper, churches hosted citywide prayer rallies, and teams conducted prayer walks through designated neighborhoods, interceding for a massive spiritual harvest and for receptive hearts at every doorstep. As a newly ordained minister in my first parish call—and determined not to be deposed for violating the LCMS Constitution, Article VI.2.c, by “participating in heterodox tract and missionary activities” before the ink was dry on my installation papers—I quietly observed from the sidelines. Then, one day, I overheard a couple of the pastors discussing a dedicated “war room” where they could discern, map, and launch targeted prayer against the spiritual strongholds they believed were binding the city. These strongholds ranged from historical land disputes and the boom-and-bust volatility of the oil and gas industry to systemic racial tensions, economic disparity, and drug abuse. Having served as a U.S. Army war plans and exercises officer representing my unit at the corps level, I was immediately intrigued by the direct application of high-level military planning frameworks to spiritual mapping. I knew a lot about the operational level of warfare (at least on the temporal plane!) and I thought: "This could be right in my wheelhouse! Maybe this is something looking into!" The Era of High Expectations Twenty-five years ago, the vocabulary of Strategic-Level Spiritual Warfare (SLSW) moved from missiology circles to conference stages: spiritual mapping, identificational repentance, binding the "principalities" over a city. C. Peter Wagner promoted it, and George Otis Jr.'s Transformations videos made it look irresistible. The promise was that if believers identified the ruling spirits, named them, and repented publicly, crime would drop, economies would surge, and revival would follow. Mostly, it did not. And when the promised breakthroughs failed to appear, the movement left behind more than disappointment. It left burnout, suspicion, and a good deal of theological fatigue. Talk of SLSW faded. But the deeper question underneath it never really went away. Did the territorial realm disappear? Old Testament scholar Michael Heiser pointed many readers back to Deuteronomy 32:8-9. Some ancient manuscripts, including the Dead Sea Scrolls and the Septuagint, say God divided the nations according to the number of the "sons of God." The Masoretic Text reads "sons of Israel," so the textual question is real. Heiser also reads Psalm 82 as a divine council whose members ruled corruptly, a reading that remains contested. Martin Luther himself took the "gods" of that psalm to be earthly rulers. Either way, Scripture keeps linking unseen powers to nations and structures (Daniel 10, Ephesians 6:12). What Luther gives us is not a map of those powers, but a way to live faithfully under them. He took the devil seriously and literally, as an enemy who attacks the church through unbelief and despair. The Large Catechism’s treatment of the Lord’s Prayer makes that clear. The Second Petition asks that God’s kingdom come and the devil’s kingdom be overthrown. The Sixth Petition names the devil, the world, and our own flesh as the ones who tempt us away from faith.The Seventh Petition asks for deliverance from evil because we live in a world still harried by the evil one. The Baptism liturgy has us renounce the devil before we do anything else. And “A Mighty Fortress” reminds us that one little word from Jesus brings him down. That is Lutheran spiritual warfare: prayed, sung, and preached—not staged. Where the old model stumbled Theologia gloriae. The peak SLSW era wanted visible victory now: measurable breakthroughs, transformed cities, and proof that the technique worked. Luther called that impulse a theology of glory. He opposed it with the theology of the cross, which finds God’s power hidden in weakness and suffering. Triumphalism also assumed an authority Scripture does not give us. Jude 9 says even Michael did not pronounce judgment on the devil, but said, “The Lord rebuke you” (see also 2 Peter 2:10-11). Technique. Prayer was sometimes treated like a key: turn it the right way, say the right words, identify the right spirit, and breakthrough would have to follow. But that is much closer to magic than to Christian petition. Neglected vocation. Attention to unseen powers sometimes became a way to avoid the slower, less dramatic work right in front of us: justice, honest institutions, neighbor-love, and the daily callings through which God serves the world. What Scripture and the Reformers model instead Prayer goes upward. In Daniel 10, Daniel does not confront the "prince of Persia." He prays and fasts, and the angel reports that his prayer was heard from the first day. God's messengers do the fighting. Our task is to appeal to God, not to taunt the powers. The Word does the work. In Acts 19, Paul does not map Ephesus or bind Artemis. He teaches daily for two years, and the Word spreads. By the end, the city clerk himself observes that Paul and his companions have not blasphemed the goddess (19:37). The gospel displaced the idols without the apostle ever attacking them by name. Civic data becomes neighbor-love. The 1990s mapping projects gathered demographics, crime statistics, and social-service audits, usually in order to identify demonic strongholds. That same information can still be useful if we read it differently. It does not reveal the name of a spirit. It shows us where our neighbors are hurting and what love might require next. Vocation carries the fight into the world. In Lutheran thought, God rules the world through the temporal order, using laws, offices, and ordinary work as what Luther called larvae Dei, God’s masks. So you do not exorcise a courthouse. You work for honest judges, faithful teachers, ethical employers, and public servants who resist corruption where they stand. Augsburg Confession XVI affirms this civil order as good. Reclaiming identificational repentance One practice from that era is worth rescuing rather than discarding: identificational repentance, the corporate confession of a family's, church's, or nation's sin. Its biblical roots are solid. Nehemiah confesses "the sins we Israelites, including myself and my father's family, have committed" (1:6), though he had not personally committed them. Daniel does the same: "we have sinned and done wrong" (9:8, 20). Jeremiah prays, "we acknowledge our wickedness... for we have sinned against you" (14:20). A generation later, the Psalms still say it: "we have sinned as our forebears did" (Psalm 106:6). Jesus addresses cities, not only individuals, for their unrepentance (Matthew 11:21-24), and the risen Jesus addresses whole congregations about their corporate sin (Revelation 2-3). Scripture treats us as families and peoples, not only as individuals, and calls leaders and priestly people to confess accordingly (1 Peter 2:9). Lutherans should recognize this instinct as familiar, not exotic. The confession that opens the Divine Service is already corporate: “we confess that we are captive to sin and cannot free ourselves.” The whole assembly says it together, whether or not each worshiper personally committed every sin that might be named that week. Identificational repentance simply extends that same pattern outward. It names the sins of a congregation’s history, or a nation’s history, and allowsthose who stand within that body to confess them before God. Where the older handouts go wrong is not the confession itself but what gets bolted onto it. "Spiritual mapping" done to locate a territory's sin, so a leader can identify and confess it, is different from spiritual mapping done to identify a specific ruling spirit to bind. The first is discernment in service of humility; the second is the triumphalism already named above. Likewise, treating "shifts in the atmosphere" or answered prayer as evidence the technique worked repeats the same theology of glory this essay has been arguing against. Confession does not purchase a result we then get to observe and report. It is simply required of us, whatever God does with it. Practiced well, identificational repentance might look like a congregation confessing its complicity in a specific injustice, its history of exclusion, or its neglect of the poor at its own doorstep. It belongs in worship, before God, without grand claims about what that confession will produce. That is not a technique for changing a city. It is ordinary Lutheran confession with a wider field of vision. Anfechtung: the fight that doesn't end None of this gives us a tidy ending. Luther knew that the devil keeps attacking the baptized, and he had a word for it: Anfechtung, the trial of faith under assault. Jesus’s presence in Word and sacrament limits the enemy’s power, but it does not spare us the fight. That is why Luther keeps pointing us back to baptism and the Word. We return to them again and again because the attack does not simply stop. Conclusion: faithful presence Let’s be plain about what this essay is and is not saying. It is not an argument that the fight has ended, or that “principalities and powers” are a first-century metaphor for bad sociology. Luther would have found that laughable, and so would I. The warfare is real, the stakes are real, and a church that stops believing it has an enemy is not more mature — it is simply disarmed. What gets rejected here is a specific set of techniques from the 1990s, not the fight itself. Even the most rigorous academic critics of territorial-spirit theory land in the same place: we still need to be engaged in spiritual warfare, on better biblical ground than a hotel war room. Spiritual warfare over cities is real, but it rarely looks like a Hollywood battle scene. More often, it looks like praying to the Lord who rebukes, preaching the Word, serving the neighbor, and doing honest work in institutions that may never thank us. We do not get to promise a transformed city on our schedule. We are called to be faithful and to trust God with the fruit. A practice to take with you this week. If the armor of God were ours to wield, triumphalism would make sense. But Isaiah 59:16–17 shows us God himself putting on the breastplate and helmet. The armor is his, and we stand in it. That is the heart of A Daily Armor Prayer, a free morning practice for people who want to resist evil from a posture of faithful presence rather than bravado. [Download it here.] Next week: Not every evil has a face. Some of it is baked into the wall itself — a system, a structure, a pattern nobody built on purpose but everybody's stuck living inside. Can deliverance ministry actually speak to something that was never a person to begin with? Part 4 of 5 asks that question directly. Rev. Dr. Steve Stutz Ordained Lutheran Pastor · Intentional Interim Minister · Certified Spiritual Director La Porte, Texas · Houston Area [Contact] · [LinkedIn] · [The Marginal Note on Substack] The Marginal Note — Theology for people who are still paying attention. Free monthly newsletter. Subscribe at Substack. ©2026 Steve Stutz. All rights reserved. Brief quotes welcome with attribution; full reprints require permission. Details at https://www.stevestutz.com (bottom of page) In Part 1 of this series, I wrote about why Christians do not need to live under the shadow of curses, whether those fears come through occult threats, wounding words, or painful family patterns. Our identity and protection rest in Jesus’s victory and in the promise given to us in Holy Baptism. Here in Part 2, I want to bring that same confidence a little closer to home—literally—to the rooms where we sleep, pray, argue, grieve, and try to rest. People ask me about their homes more often than you might think. I am not a handyman, a structural engineer, or a real-estate agent. Still, my inbox regularly includes messages from people trying to describe something they can barely name: a bedroom that suddenly feels heavy, a child who no longer sleeps peacefully, a basement corner everyone avoids, or a sense in the house that something is off and does not seem to lift after a quick prayer.
That is what I mean by “ground-level deliverance”: ordinary pastoral care for households carrying real distress in the real rooms where they live. It is not flashy. It is not meant to be dramatic. It takes material facts seriously. It takes spiritual need seriously. And it tries to do both without spectacle, superstition, or speculation. One family comes to mind. They had recently moved into a charming older home in an established neighborhood. (The family accounts presented in this essay are composite stories, with identifying details altered to preserve pastoral confidentiality.) Within a few weeks, their youngest child began waking in fear and pointing toward the closet. The parents had tried the ordinary things first: nightlights, soft music, bedtime routines, and prayers. Even so, they noticed that they, too, felt uneasy whenever they entered that room. Sometimes a household can name difficult associations with a place: grief, abuse, violence, occult involvement, or a season of profound suffering. At other times there is no visible history at all, which can be its own kind of distress. Most of the time, these are not people chasing the paranormal. They are parishioners and neighbors who have run out of easy explanations and are carrying a weight they do not know how to set down. What they need first is not a dramatic pronouncement. They need someone to listen carefully, take them seriously, and refuse both ridicule and fear. That is where I try to begin: at the kitchen table, with patience, prayer, and a willingness to ask ordinary questions before reaching for extraordinary conclusions. Two Ways Pastoral Care Can Go Wrong I do not automatically leap to a supernatural explanation. But I also do not assume that spiritual care has nothing to offer. Faithful ministry in moments like these has to walk carefully between two opposite mistakes. The first is spiritual overreach: treating every strange sound, environmental quirk, psychological symptom, or hard family season as evidence of demonic activity. This amplifies fear, imports sensationalized frameworks foreign to the sobriety of Scripture, and can leave a family more frightened than when the pastor arrived. The second is pastoral reductionism: treating every report of spiritual distress as merely a symptom, an old house settling, or a problem to hand off without prayerful attention. This isolates people and tells them the Church has nothing to say when a home no longer feels safe. The Christian tradition offers a more grounded path. It lets us take the material world seriously, honor ordinary forms of care, refuse superstition, and still bear witness to the peace of Jesus in the actual places where people live. Creation, Incarnation, and Peace The modern Western Church can slip into a quiet kind of practical dualism. We may speak as if God cares deeply about souls, ideas, and private feelings, but not quite as much about timber, drywall, soil, meals, bedrooms, and neighborhoods. Scripture does not let us divide the world that way. In Genesis 1, the Spirit of God hovers over the face of the deep. Creation is not an accidental container for spiritual things. It is sustained, loved, and claimed by God. A home is not merely a financial asset or a backdrop for private religious experience. It is where people sleep, grieve, raise children, prepare food, welcome neighbors, argue, reconcile, and rest. Material spaces matter because embodied people matter. And then there is John 20. The disciples are behind locked doors because they are afraid. Jesus comes and stands among them and says, “Peace be with you.” Then he breathes on them and says, “Receive the Holy Spirit.” That detail has always mattered to me: the risen Christ is not a vague religious idea floating above real life. He meets frightened people in the room where they actually are. He is not absent from bedrooms, kitchens, hospital rooms, basements, or homes burdened by grief and fear. The Church need not be embarrassed by prayer offered in homes, workplaces, and neighborhoods. Jesus’s peace is not confined to sanctuaries. What Burdens a Household? It is tempting to ask, “What happened here?” and then hunt for a hidden spiritual mechanism. Sometimes that question is appropriate. More often the wiser question is: “What is burdening this household now?” A household may carry grief, family conflict, sleep disruption, illness, traumatic memory, financial pressure, isolation, unsafe conditions, or painful associations with a property’s past. These causes overlap. Scripture does teach that human sin wounds persons, communities, and creation. Abel’s blood cries out from the ground (Gen. 4:10). Numbers 35:33–34 and Leviticus 18:24–28 speak seriously about violence, bloodshed, idolatry, and the land. Those texts remind us that violence and injustice are never merely private matters, and that God takes them seriously. That being said, we still need to be careful about claiming that a particular house retains measurable spiritual residue or that we can identify a demonic attachment to a location with certainty. A place may be associated with severe grief, violence, abuse, addiction, or loss. A household may feel real fear connected to what happened there, whether they experienced it themselves or learned about it after moving in. A pastor need not decide whether the distress is “merely psychological” or “certainly spiritual.” Whatever the mix of causes, the burden is real. It deserves patient listening, prayer, practical support, and, when appropriate, medical, mental-health, or trauma-informed care. A family may also discover objects, vows, or practices connected with occultism, divination, or idolatry. Christians may rightly renounce what contradicts their faith. Objects can be removed responsibly, former involvement confessed, and freedom and faithfulness asked of God. But the goal is not to uncover hidden “rights” held by evil powers. It is to say plainly: “This household belongs to Jesus Christ.” A Pastoral Assessment When I enter a home where something feels terribly wrong, I try to slow everything down. The goal is not to diagnose demons. It is to care for people responsibly, truthfully, and without fear. So, I start with the ordinary, not because the ordinary is all there is, but because love pays attention to what can actually be seen, checked, repaired, and cared for. Before assuming a spiritual cause, check the house. Carbon monoxide, mold, electrical problems, structural noises, rodents, plumbing, HVAC problems, poor ventilation, and persistent noise can all contribute to a sense that something is wrong. Safety hazards require practical intervention, not spiritual interpretation. Then check on the people. When did this begin? Who is affected? Has there been a death, a move, an illness, a job loss, a conflict, or another major change? Is anyone sleeping poorly, experiencing panic or grief, taking new medication, or struggling with another health concern? Trauma, sleep disruption, anxiety, substance use, neurological conditions, and other medical or psychological issues can profoundly shape a person's experience of a room. That does not make anyone foolish or faithless. It means they need care. Medical evaluation, counseling, and pastoral prayer are not competing explanations. They can be companions in caring for the same frightened, exhausted, embodied person. The wise pastor does not force a false choice between them. And then there is the spiritual need. A household may need prayer, confession, Scripture, blessing, and the steady proclamation of Jesus’s peace without anyone ever determining whether the disturbance was definitively supernatural. That is especially true when fear, guilt, estrangement from God, former occult practices, trauma, or loss have begun to interfere with ordinary sleep, hospitality, worship, and rest. “Is It a Demon?” Sooner or later, someone usually asks the question directly. Often it comes quietly at the kitchen table: “Do you think it’s a demon?” When that happens, I try to answer without pretending to know more than I know. I might say: “I don’t know, and I don’t think anyone can know that from the outside. What I do know is that you’re afraid, and that’s real. We’ll make sure the house is safe. We’ll make sure everyone is cared for. And we’ll pray together in the name of Jesus, who is stronger than whatever this is, if it is anything. If this goes beyond what I can responsibly handle, I’ll tell you, and we’ll bring in others.” That answer refuses both ridicule and false certainty, which is most of the work. It also gives the family something calmer than fear to hold onto. Safeguards Do not do this alone. Bring a second person, especially where children are involved, and follow your congregation’s and synod’s safe-church and boundary policies. Know your reporting obligations for suspected abuse. When a situation exceeds ordinary pastoral care, escalate the circle, not the drama. Involve appropriate medical or mental-health professionals, your bishop or synod office, and experienced colleagues. Keep clinical care in place, and be candid about the limits of what you can do. Blessing, Renunciation, and Deliverance Prayer For an ordinary household visit, a routine blessing from the pastoral visitation book is usually enough. That may sound simple, but simple is not the same as shallow. In my own pastoral practice, I keep home visits within deprecatory prayer: asking God to protect the home, guard those who sleep there, give peace to those who are afraid, and keep evil from them. I do not turn the visit into verbal combat with alleged spiritual forces. The baptismal renunciations give households a better instrument than any pastor’s command. “Do you renounce the devil and all the forces that defy God?” That language belongs to every baptized Christian. A family that says together, in their own voices, that they renounce what is evil and belong to Jesus is doing something a pastor cannot do for them. Where a situation seems to exceed this, I do not improvise. I consult. Jesus’s Promise, Not Spiritual Technique When the Church ministers in a troubled home, we do not rely on secret knowledge, elaborate rituals, sage, incantations, or theatrical displays. We rely on the ordinary gifts God has given: Word, prayer, repentance, forgiveness, baptismal promise, Christian community, and the name of Jesus Christ. Many traditions bless a home with water, oil, the sign of the cross, Scripture, hymns, and prayers in each room. These can be meaningful and pastorally helpful, but they are not magic charms. They do not work automatically. They are not spiritual technologies by which a pastor gains control over evil. A simple analogy may help. A gold band does not create love. It publicly testifies to a covenant already made. In the same way, a cross in the hallway, a psalm read aloud in a bedroom, or oil used in a prayer of blessing testifies that this household seeks to live under Jesus’s mercy. The sign is not the source of power. Jesus is. A Simple Pastoral Pattern When a household asks for help, I would reduce the pastoral response to four movements: 1. Listen and assess. Hear the family’s story without mockery or interrogation. Ask about safety, sleep, health, recent stressors, and the history they know. 2. Address what can be addressed. Check practical safety concerns. Encourage appropriate professional care. If the household wants to renounce former occult or idolatrous practices, pray a simple confession of faith in Jesus and a renunciation of what contradicts him. 3. Pray and bless the home. Read Scripture aloud and pray for peace, protection, rest, healing, reconciliation, and Jesus’s presence in each room. Use water, oil, or the sign of the cross only as your church’s practice allows. 4. Establish life-giving habits. Follow up. The blessing is not a one-time technique. Teach the household to pray, remember baptism, worship, share meals, practice reconciliation, and remain connected to the congregation. A pastor does not need to stage a dramatic confrontation in order to minister faithfully. Often, it is enough to stand with the family, speak the promises of God clearly, and pray words they can keep praying after the pastor leaves: “Jesus Christ is Lord. This household belongs to him. May the peace of Christ guard all who live here. May God protect this home from evil, strengthen those who are afraid, and make this place a dwelling of faith, mercy, rest, and love.” Conclusion: Back to the Closet When we stepped into that child’s bedroom, we did not find a demonic presence hiding in the shadow of the closet door. We found a drafty window frame that made a soft whistling sound when the wind came from the north. We also found a child carrying the strain of a recent cross-country move and a season of separation anxiety. So, the window was sealed, a soft nightlight was added, and we stood by the bed and prayed a simple prayer asking God to guard the room and give the child peaceful sleep. A week later, sleep had begun to return. Fear had not vanished by magic, but it no longer owned the room. That is often what ground-level deliverance looks like. It is not simply about driving away whatever frightens us. It is about helping people live freely, safely, and faithfully under Jesus’s lordship. A Christian home is not secured by fear, technique, or a pastor’s dramatic authority. It is formed day by day through the ordinary gifts of God: prayer offered in weakness, Scripture read aloud, meals shared, forgiveness practiced, children comforted, and Jesus’s peace spoken into real anxiety. The Church need not pretend to know more than it knows. It can check the wiring, honor the physician and the counselor, refuse both ridicule and spectacle, and pray: “The Lord bless you and keep you; the Lord make his face to shine upon you, and be gracious to you; the Lord lift up his countenance upon you, and give you peace.” (Numbers 6:24–26, NRSV) A practice to go with this week. Whatever you think about that house on the cul-de-sac, you still have to walk into rooms. Ephesians 6 talks about shoes: being ready to carry the peace of Christ into the places we go. A Daily Armor Prayer is a free morning practice that helps you do that, one step and one room at a time. It's short, it's rooted in Scripture, and it fits into a few quiet minutes. [Download it here.] Next week in Part 3 of Deliverance in Context: So far, we have looked at deliverance where most of us actually live: in our homes, our families, and the ordinary places where fear and distress take root. But what happens when we widen the lens? What if the “place” that concerns us is no longer a bedroom or a house, but a neighborhood, a city, or a whole community? In the next installment, we will step into the controversial world of Strategic-Level Spiritual Warfare—spiritual mapping, territorial spirits, prayer walking, “war rooms,” and the practice of identificational repentance. There is real biblical language about unseen powers and their relationship to nations and structures. But there is also a long history of Christians turning that reality into spiritual technique and triumphalism. So, we will ask a distinctly Lutheran question: “What does spiritual warfare look like when we stop trying to conquer the territory and instead become faithfully present in it?” Rev. Dr. Steve Stutz Ordained Lutheran Pastor · Intentional Interim Minister · Certified Spiritual Director La Porte, Texas · Houston Area [Contact] · [LinkedIn] · [The Marginal Note on Substack] The Marginal Note — Theology for people who are still paying attention. Free monthly newsletter. Subscribe at Substack. ©2026 Steve Stutz. All rights reserved. Brief quotes welcome with attribution; full reprints require permission. Details at https://www.stevestutz.com (bottom of page) A few years ago, someone called me sounding genuinely frightened. She had found a strange little trinket near her doorstep, along with a hostile note wishing harm on her family.
"Am I cursed?" she asked, her voice trembling. "What do I do?" In a culture fascinated by astrology, tarot, and modern witchcraft, even devout Christians quietly wonder: Can a curse actually harm me? And if I feel spiritually attacked, what do I do? The Christian tradition does not meet that fear with mockery, denial, or fascination. It meets it with steady theology, honest attention to the wounds people carry, and practical pastoral care—all resting on the One who has already claimed you in Holy Baptism. Not All "Curses" Come from a Fortune Teller When we hear the word "curse," most of us picture something dramatic: the “evil eye,” a carnival fortune teller, or some creepy object bought at a flea market. But in real life, the most common—and often the most damaging—"curses" are usually much closer to home. They are spoken judgments, lingering wounds, and toxic patterns that get lodged deep in a person's soul:
Do Spiritual Curses Have Any Real Power? Christian tradition understands an occult curse as an intentional attempt to call on evil powers to harm someone. That can sound terrifying. But Scripture is remarkably unimpressed by such attempts against God's people:
Think of a curse as a letter with a forged signature. It may look official. It may even frighten you for a moment. But it carries no true authority, because the One whose name actually matters has already signed something different over your life. In Baptism, Jesus placed His name upon you. That is why the note on that person’s doorstep mattered, but not in the way she feared. The person who left it most likely wanted to create terror. A threat meant to be found is intimidation, not sorcery. It only works if it tricks us into handing over our peace. In many cultures, tales are told of sorcerers naming someone for death. The story almost always turns on belief: the village believes it, the victim believes it, and terror and isolation do the rest. When someone dies, it is remembered as proof. The many for whom nothing happened are forgotten. A threat like this lives in shared belief. That is why the Church's task is to be the community that flatly refuses to believe the lie, surrounding the frightened person with blessing and truth instead. What About Hidden Threats? I told the person who called me about that strange object that if someone truly skilled in this sort of thing had been trying to harm her family, she probably would not have found the item at all. Malifices tends to work best in secret. Still, that leaves a lingering worry: What if there's a hidden curse or object I haven't found? The answer is still the same. Your safety does not depend on being vigilant enough, spiritually spotless enough, or perceptive enough. It rests entirely on Jesus’s completed victory. Unrepented sin, occult involvement, and agreeing with lies do matter, not because they cancel God's protection, but because they pull us away from the One who protects us. If you are prone to scrupulosity, please hear this gently: God's protection is not a fragile system you must keep from crashing. Even in cases of genuine spiritual harassment, the remedy is never panic or improvised rituals. It is returning to God through the ordinary means of grace, with your pastor's help. What Can Every Believer Do? You do not need a special title or a dramatic deliverance service to walk in freedom. In the Christian tradition, the baptized already have real vocations as believers, parents, neighbors, and members of a household. Here are some ordinary, sturdy practices:
Where the Pastor Comes In Any Christian can speak the comfort of the Gospel to a neighbor. A pastor's role is different, but not because a pastor has some personal spiritual power that ordinary Christians lack. A pastor speaks publicly on behalf of the Church by virtue of a public call. That distinction matters. It protects believers from spiritual overreach, clericalism, and emotional manipulation. When persistent distress or deep guilt remains, a pastor can offer, on the Church's behalf:
When to Seek Other Help Spiritual care and professional care are not mutually exclusive. They work hand in hand. Persistent anxiety, intrusive thoughts, deep hopelessness, or chronic sleeplessness deserve the attention of a physician or licensed mental health professional. There is no shame in that. Wise pastors often refer parishioners to clinical help and work alongside therapists. If you or someone you know is experiencing thoughts of self-harm, call or text 988 in the U.S. for immediate support. Additionally, if you receive a genuinely threatening note or suspicious object on your property, take a photograph, do not confront anyone, keep the evidence, and report it to local law enforcement. Blessing your enemy and locking your doors are completely compatible actions. Living in the Light So, back to that phone call. We did not panic. We did not hunt for counter-spells or search the internet for clearing rituals. We prayed together, asked God to bless the person who left the item, took comfort in Jesus’s promises, and left the rest in His hands. She also kept the note and reported the incident to local authorities. Luther once observed that the best way to drive out the devil, when he will not yield to texts of Scripture, is to flout and mock him, for he cannot endure scorn. Whether you are carrying an old judgment spoken by a parent years ago or facing a threatening trinket left on your porch today, the Christian response is never panic or fascination. It is simple, joyful nearness to Jesus Christ. When the Word of God has secured your identity, no word spoken against you gets the final word. If a wounding word has been echoing in you, the answer isn't to fight it harder. It's to be re-anchored in what is true. I've prepared a free companion to this series, A Daily Armor Prayer, a short morning practice based on Ephesians 6. It begins with the Belt of Truth: a daily return to what God says about you in Christ. [Download it here.] Scripture quotations are from the English Standard Version (ESV). This is the first in a five part series called “Deliverance in Context—From the ground up!” Next week: Ground Level Deliverance: There’s Something Not Quite Right About That One House on the Cul-de-Sac. Every neighborhood has one. The house nobody can quite explain, the room that never feels right, the place where three different families all left in a hurry. What pastoral care for a place actually looks like, and why “just pray about it” isn’t an answer. Rev. Dr. Steve Stutz Ordained Lutheran Pastor · Intentional Interim Minister · Certified Spiritual Director La Porte, Texas · Houston Area [Contact] · [LinkedIn] · [The Marginal Note on Substack] The Marginal Note — Theology for people who are still paying attention. Free monthly newsletter. Subscribe at Substack. ©2026 Steve Stutz. All rights reserved. Brief quotes welcome with attribution; full reprints require permission. Details at https://www.stevestutz.com (bottom of page) Somewhere along the way, “calling” started to mean the work you would gladly do even if nobody paid you for it: your passion, your purpose, the thing you were supposedly made for. That sounds beautiful, of course. But it can also put a heavy burden on an ordinary Tuesday. It sets an impossibly high bar for most real jobs, and it is not what Luther meant by the word in the first place.
So if your job does not feel like a calling in that modern sense — if it is mostly how you pay the bills, not something you would frame on the wall — it may be worth taking a breath before deciding something has gone wrong. The older meaning of the word may fit your actual life better than the modern one does. The word is Beruf, and it was not mainly about fulfillment Before the Reformation, vocation usually meant one thing: a call to religious life. Monks, nuns, and priests had vocations. Most everyone else simply had work to do — necessary work, sometimes honorable work, but not work people tended to describe as spiritually significant. Luther challenged that hierarchy on purpose. His German word, Beruf, applied to everyone — the farmer, the magistrate, the mother, the cobbler, the milkmaid at her pail — with no lower tier. Underneath that shift was the priesthood of all believers: every baptized Christian stands before God on the same footing. That means every station in life can become a place to serve God, not only the obviously religious ones. You may be wearing a mask, and that is a compliment Luther had a strange but vivid image for this: larvae Dei, the masks of God. God feeds the world, Luther said, but usually not by doing it directly. He does it through the farmer growing the grain, the baker making the bread, and the person at the register handing it to you at the end of a long day. Ordinary work is one of the ways God does ordinary things in the world. The person doing the work is, in a sense, wearing God’s mask for that particular task. That may sound like a strange thing to say about a shift at a call center, a warehouse, or any job that mostly leaves you tired. But if you take it seriously, it becomes a deeply dignifying claim about work the culture rarely treats as dignified. The job does not have to feel personally meaningful every hour for it to be doing something real. Its meaning comes from the neighbor it serves, not from how inspired you feel while doing it. The neighbor is the point, even when the paycheck matters Here is the practical shift: if you are waiting to feel called before your job counts as a calling, the focus has quietly moved toward your own fulfillment. Luther’s version points in the other direction. The calling is recognized by looking at who is being served: the coworker who needed the shift covered, the customer who needed the problem solved, the family the paycheck supports. That is where the calling shows up — not in your enthusiasm level on a Thursday afternoon. This is not a way of talking yourself into liking a bad job. Bad jobs are still bad. Underpaid, mistreated, precarious work does not become fine because you have found a theological frame for it. But it does mean the dignity of the work is not dependent on the work also being your passion. You do not have to love it for it to count. Two kinds of calling, not one It helps to separate two things our language tends to collapse into one word. There is the general call — the call to faith itself, the same for every Christian and not tied to any job. And there is the specific call — your actual station in life right now: this job, this family, this set of responsibilities, whatever it currently is. The specific call can change. It can eveninclude a job you are actively trying to leave. It does not need to become your permanent identity in order to be the place where you are currently living out the general call. That distinction does a lot of quiet work. It means you can be faithfully called to a job you are also trying to get out of. Those two things are not necessarily in conflict. The calling is not an endorsement of the job’s rightness for your whole life. It is a claim about what is actually happening while you are there. If you are between callings right now If you are unemployed, underemployed, or between jobs entirely, this framework still holds, even though it can be harder to see from there. The searching itself — the applications, the waiting, the interviews that go nowhere — is not a gap in your vocation. It is what your specific calling looks like at the moment, however unwelcome that may be. Dignity in this framework was never tied to having landed the job. It was tied to something underneath employment status entirely, which means it does not switch off during the gap. That is not comfort dressed up as theology. It is simply this: whatever you are doing right now to get through this stretch is not outside the reach of what Luther was describing. It is inside it. Rev. Dr. Steve Stutz Ordained Lutheran Pastor · Intentional Interim Minister · Certified Spiritual Director La Porte, Texas · Houston Area [Contact] · [LinkedIn] · [The Marginal Note on Substack] The Marginal Note — Theology for people who are still paying attention. Free monthly newsletter. Subscribe at Substack. ©2026 Steve Stutz. All rights reserved. Brief quotes welcome with attribution; full reprints require permission. Details at https://www.stevestutz.com (bottom of page) A friend tells you they’re sick. Someone you love admits they’re scared. Another person quietly says their marriage is coming apart. And almost without thinking, you say, “I’ll pray for you.” You mean it. Of course you do. But then, if you’re honest, you may not be entirely sure what happens next. Do you whisper one sentence in the moment and call it done? Add their name to a mental list you’ll probably lose by Thursday? Wait for church and hope their name comes back to you during the prayers of the people?
After twenty-eight years in ministry, I’ve come to believe that many of us were never actually taught how to do this. We were told that Christians should pray for one another, and we believed it. But few of us were given a simple, livable way to carry another person’s need past the moment when we first heard it. So we fall back on a sincere impulse, call it intercession, and then feel vaguely guilty when it fades faster than we meant it to. Why Pray at All? Before we talk about how to pray, it helps to name the quiet question many of us carry but do not always say out loud: If God is really God, why do I need to tell Him what is happening? If He is sovereign and His purposes are already unfolding, why open my mouth at all? Doesn’t He already know what my friend needs? He does. But intercession is not only about informing God. It is also about letting God draw us into His care for the world. Prayer slows us down long enough to notice another person’s burden, softens what has grown hurried or numb in us, and gives us a real part in loving our neighbor. God does not ordain only the ends; He ordains the means. In His providence, He freely chooses to do particular goods through the prayers of His people. So we pray seriously and persistently, while remaining humble enough not to claim that we can trace every outcome back to one particular prayer. Across Christian history, both liturgical and evangelical traditions have treated intercession as a normal way of loving one’s neighbor. Think of Monica, who wept and prayed for years over her wayward son until an unnamed bishop — worn down by her persistence — finally told her that “it cannot be that the son of these tears should perish” (Augustine, Confessions III.12). Augustine later understood his conversion within the providence of God, and Monica’s faithful prayers were woven deeply into that story. When Martin Luther addressed this in his Large Catechism (1529), he did not get lost in speculation. He pointed to two steady pillars: command and promise. Prayer, he says, rests on obedience to the God who commands us to pray — and because God has attached His promise to that command, Luther is confident God “will not suffer our prayers to be in vain or lost.” Refusing to intercede because of a lofty view of God’s sovereignty is not deeper theology; it can become disobedience dressed up as humility. We do not pray to manage Heaven’s inbox. We pray because God has invited us to bring our neighbor’s needs before Him, and because He has promised to meet us in the asking. So here is a simple place to begin — not because prayer is a technique to master, but because a habit needs a shape if it is going to survive an ordinary, busy week. Start with a List Good intentions are not enough by themselves. If “I’ll keep you in my prayers” is never written down somewhere you will see it again, it may remain a sincere feeling rather than become a steady practice. Keep it simple: a notecard, a notes app, the inside cover of your Bible. Write the name. Write one line about what they are facing. That is enough. A list does something a feeling cannot: it makes forgetting visible. You may notice that a name has been sitting there for three weeks without being spoken to God. That is useful information, not a reason for shame. It is simply an invitation to begin again with the person still in front of you. Pray by Name “Be with everyone who is struggling” is a real prayer, and it is not nothing. But intercession becomes more loving when it becomes particular: this person, this situation, this need, brought honestly before God instead of waved at from a distance. When Luther wrote his little guide on prayer for his barber, Peter Beskendorf (A Simple Way to Pray, 1535), his counselwas wonderfully practical. Do not let prayer dissolve into vague goodwill. Say the name. Say what is actually happening. Pray specifically enough that, if God grants help, you would recognize the mercy. Give It a Rhythm Once a day, tied to something you already do — coffee, the drive to work, brushing your teeth — run down the list. It does not need to be long. A sentence per name is enough, spoken aloud or silently. What matters most is that prayer has somewhere ordinary to live in your day, instead of depending on a burst of willpower after everything else is already loud. Luther urged Peter to guard this daily time against procrastination, warning him about the tempting thought that prayer can wait “a little while” until the next urgent task is finished. Those small delays are often how a whole day passes with no prayer at all. If mornings do not work for you, try evenings. If daily is too much to sustain honestly, weekly is better than a daily practice you abandon by the second week and never restart. A prayer list you actually keep is better than an ambitious one that quietly dies. When Words Run Out Sometimes the situation is too tangled to know what outcome to ask for. A marriage may be so broken that you cannot simply pray, “Fix it,” as if you know what faithfulness requires. A diagnosis may be so grave that “heal them” is a true longing, but not the only honest prayer you can bring. Paul names this directly in Romans: the Spirit intercedes for us with groans too deep for words when we do not know how to pray as we ought (Romans 8:26). That is not a loophole for becoming vague or careless. It is permission to bring the situation honestly, without pretending you know the right outcome, and to trust that prayer does not depend on you finding perfect words. When you are stuck, borrow a simple tool from Luther’s own practice: a four-strand “garland” he used to pray through each phrase. Begin with instruction: what promise or truth from Scripture speaks to this suffering? Move to thanksgiving: what is one good thing you can genuinely thank God for in this person’s life right now? Then confession: where does your own powerlessness, fear, or desire to control the outcome need to be laid down? Finally, petition: what specific request are you handing over — “Lord, take this mess and hold them in it,” not just a softer version of the same anxiety. You are nottrying to orchestrate the outcome. You are anchoring your friend to the character of God. When Nothing Changes Every seasoned intercessor eventually learns this painful truth: sometimes we pray for years and the sickness still wins, the marriage still ends, or the wayward child still does not come home. Christians do not measure the worth of prayer only by what we can see. We bring the person to the Father through Jesus, trusting that Jesus’s own intercession is never futile, even when the outcome we asked for is not granted. To keep naminga friend before God when nothing seems to be changing is not wasted energy. It is quiet, stubborn faithfulness. It is love that keeps showing up when there is no visible progress to reward it. Let Prayer Move You Prayer may also open our eyes to a concrete act of love that is ours to do: making a phone call, bringing a meal, sitting in a waiting room, helping arrange care, or encouraging someone to seek wise professional help. Sometimes the next faithful prayer is followed by the next faithful errand. We should not use prayer as a substitute for the practical love that prayer itself awakens. When we ask God to care for someone, we should be ready to become part of His care if He gives us something to do. Tell Them You’re Praying Not as a performance, but as encouragement. “I’ve been praying for you by name every morning” lands differently than “I’ll pray for you” said once and never mentioned again. It closes the loop. It tells the person that your prayer was not a polite reflex; it became an actual practice they were included in. Why It Matters We have quietly outsourced a lot of intercession — to prayer chains, to “thoughts and prayers” as a kind of condolence, to the comforting assumption that someone, somewhere, is surely doing the praying so we do not have to. None of that is malicious. It is what happens when a practice is commended but not taught, and we are left to improvise. Luther warned that if we wait until we feel like praying, or until we have the perfect words, we may never pray at all. Intercession is not sending warm feelings in someone’s direction. It is a spiritual duty, yes, but also a form of love. When you speak your neighbor’s name before God, you are standing with them — and sometimes for them — when they maybe too exhausted to pray for themselves. So the next time you say, “I’ll pray for you,” let it become more than a kind sentence in a hard moment. Write the name down. Bring it before God. Return to it tomorrow. Intercession does not have to be complicated to be faithful. A list. A name. A rhythm. Offered on purpose, with love, more than once. Rev. Dr. Steve Stutz Ordained Lutheran Pastor · Intentional Interim Minister · Certified Spiritual Director La Porte, Texas · Houston Area [Contact] · [LinkedIn] · [The Marginal Note on Substack] The Marginal Note — Theology for people who are still paying attention. Free monthly newsletter. Subscribe at Substack. ©2026 Steve Stutz. All rights reserved. Brief quotes welcome with attribution; full reprints require permission. Details at https://www.stevestutz.com (bottom of page) Most advice about Sabbath sounds like it was written for people who already have room to breathe. Turn off your phone. Leave the errands alone. Let the inbox wait. That is good advice, but it can land hard when every hour feels claimed already. If you are picking up gig shifts, working a second job, caring for your family, or searching for work with the kind of urgency that makes rest feel irresponsible, the problem is not that Sabbath is a bad idea. The problem is that the usual advice may not be speaking to the life you are actually living right now.
So let’s be honest about Sabbath when a full day of rest simply is not possible — not in theory, but in the actual week sitting in front of you. Sabbath Was Never Really About Having Nothing to Do The commandment was not first given to people with open calendars and flexible schedules. It was given to a people who had just left slavery — people who knew what it meant to have rest refused to them. In Exodus 20:8–11 and Deuteronomy 5:12–15, Sabbath is not presented as a perk for people who have finished everything. It is a sign that God’s people are no longer owned by endless labor. Martin Luther says something similar in his treatment of the Third Commandment in the Large Catechism. The day of rest exists for ordinary people, servants, and laborers, “that for a day they may retire in order to rest and be refreshed.” Rest is required “so that both man and beast might recuperate, and not be weakened by unremitting labor.” In other words, the call to stop is not, “You’ve earned a break.” It is, “You are not a slave anymore, and the proof is that you are allowed to stop.” Sabbath protects the worker’s body, but it also tells the truth about the worker’s worth: you are not only what you produce. So if your honest question is, “What if I truly cannot afford a full day off?” that is not a sign that you have failed the commandment. It is a hard circumstance, and sometimes a painful one. The commandment is not blind to that kind of pressure. Scripture makes room for real necessity: an ox in a ditch, acts of mercy, healing that cannot wait. The principle survives contact with hard constraints because it was made for real human lives, not ideal ones. What This Isn't This is not a productivity hack with a spiritual label slapped on it. “Rest better so you can work harder” misses the point. Sabbath is not another way to optimize yourself. And it is not another reason to feel guilty because you cannot manage a full day of stillness in a season that will not allow it. Measuring your Sabbath by whether you hit a perfect twenty-four-hour mark can turn a promise into another performance. It can make God’s gift feel like one more assignment you are already behind on. Luther warned against treating the commandments as a new spiritual burden; they are not meant to crush people who are already tired. If this season only allows for an hour, take the hour, and let it truly be Sabbath instead of treating it like a smaller version of failure. That does not mean a partial practice has to stay partial forever if your circumstances change. It only means grace can meet you where you actually are. Start Smaller Than a Day If a full day is off the table, Sabbath does not have to arrive in a twenty-four-hour block to be real. It can be an hour. It can be a meal. It can be putting your phone away and actually keeping that boundary. For some people, that hour will come late at night or early in the morning — the only opening the week gives them. That still counts. The theological point is not the exact length of time. It is the act of stopping on purpose, even briefly, to listen to something larger than your own survival. Sunday morning worship can be that one sacred hour when nobody gets to demand your labor. A family dinner with notifications off can become unhurried holy ground. Even the fifteen-minute commute between shifts can be spent in quiet instead of job alerts, mental math, or work-related noise. An hour kept faithfully every week can do more than a perfect day you keep planning and then losing under pressure. Before that hour begins, give yourself one small signal that this time is different. Close the laptop and set it in another room. Step outside. Light a candle. Or simply say out loud, “This hour is not for work.” The boundary does not have to be dramatic. It only has to remind you who gets to interrupt you — and who does not. Separate "Can't Stop Working" from "Can't Stop Striving" There is a difference between the hours you are actually on shift and the hours you spend anxious about work while technically off it — refreshing job boards at 11 p.m., running numbers in your head at dinner, carrying the job search into every unscheduled minute. The first may be a real economic constraint. The second is often anxiety wearing a productivity mask. Sabbath cannot give you more hours, but it can give you permission to stop inventing work when none is required of you. That, too, is a real form of Sabbath, even inside a week that has no room for a full one. Let It Be Communal, Not Just Personal In Scripture, Sabbath was never only a private discipline. It was something a household and a community practicedtogether. If your week has little room for solitary rest, look for the kind that happens in company: a shared meal where nobody checks their phone, Sunday worship as one hour genuinely set apart, or a standing coffee with someone who will not immediately ask what you have lined up next. Rest does not have to happen alone to count. For many people, shared rest is the version that is most possible — and most sustaining. The Stopping Is the Point Whatever size Sabbath comes in — an hour, a meal, a walk without your phone — the stopping itself is doing the theological work. It reminds you, week by week, that you are not only as valuable as your last shift, your last application,or your last productive hour. That was true for people who had just left slavery, and it is true for you now, in whatever version of rest this week can actually hold. This week, pick one hour. Not the perfect hour — just one you can protect. Put it in your calendar as a recurring appointment, and treat the reminder the way you would treat a shift you cannot miss. When it comes, do one thing: stop calculating. Let the hour be received instead of achieved. That is Sabbath, and for now, it is enough. Rev. Dr. Steve Stutz Ordained Lutheran Pastor · Intentional Interim Minister · Certified Spiritual Director La Porte, Texas · Houston Area [Contact] · [LinkedIn] · [The Marginal Note on Substack] The Marginal Note — Theology for people who are still paying attention. Free monthly newsletter. Subscribe at Substack. ©2026 Steve Stutz. All rights reserved. Brief quotes welcome with attribution; full reprints require permission. Details at https://www.stevestutz.com (bottom of page) |
AuthorRev. Dr. Steve Stutz is an ordained pastor with nearly three decades of ministry in parish, retreat, and teaching settings. He holds a Doctor of Ministry in spiritual direction and serves as an adjunct professor, teaching courses in spiritual direction and discernment. His work focuses on helping individuals and congregations listen more carefully for the movement of the Holy Spirit in everyday life. Through spiritual direction, pastoral consultation, and writing, he explores themes of discernment, spiritual formation, dreams, and the sometimes perplexing experiences that arise in the life of faith. Steve has served congregations in a variety of contexts and currently offers spiritual direction, pastoral consultation, and retreat leadership. When he is not writing or meeting with directees, he enjoys reading widely in theology, philosophy, and the Christian contemplative tradition. Learn more about his work at stevestutz.com. Archives
November 2026
Categories
All
|